| IHOF BOWL 1 (2004) |
 |
16-3-0 |
Fairbanks Northstars 23 |
Houston Mustangs 7 |
13-7-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 2 (2005) |
 |
17-3-0 |
Superior Intellectuals 30 |
Snapfinger Jazz 14 |
14-5-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 3 (2006) |
 |
15-4-0 |
North Plainfield Plague 10 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 7 |
14-5-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 4 (2007) |
|
17-2-0 |
North Plainfield Plague 27 |
Outer Banks Ospreys 14 |
12-8-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 5 (2008) |
|
15-4-0 |
Fairbanks Northstars 19 |
North Plainfield Plague 17 |
16-3-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 6 (2009) |
 |
15-4-0 |
Frederick Red Menace 28 |
San Antonio Volunteers 14 |
14-5-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 7 (2010) |
 |
15-4-0 |
Syracuse Mohawks 34 |
Frederick Red Menace 31 |
15-4-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 8 (2011) |
|
15-4-0 |
Frederick Red Menace 24 |
Vicksburg Vipers 18 |
13-6-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 9 (2012) |
|
14-6-0 |
Vicksburg Vipers 27 |
Superior Intellectuals 23 |
15-4-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 10 (2013) |
 |
15-4-0 |
Rochester Lake Monsters 32 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 29 |
15-4-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 11 (2014) |
 |
19-0-0 |
Boston Rhinos 21 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 14 |
16-3-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 12 (2015) |
 |
16-3-0 |
Fort Worth Fury 28 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 24 |
13-7-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 13 (2016) |
 |
18-1-0 |
Orlando Knights 41 |
Neverland Ranch Hands 21 |
13-7-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 14 (2017) |
|
16-4-0 |
Syracuse Mohawks 28 |
Williamsburg Colonials 14 |
13-7-0 |
 |
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 15 (2018) |
|
17-2-0 |
Orlando Knights 41 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 27 |
14-5-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 16 (2019) |
 |
16-3-0 |
Asheville Axemen 28 |
Houston Mustangs 26 |
14-5-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 17 (2020) |
 |
17-3-0 |
Tucker Tigers 29 |
Asheville Axemen 21 |
14-5-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 18 (2021) |
|
16-3-0 |
Chesapeake Chitterlings 37 |
Tucker Tigers 22 |
15-5-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 19 (2022) |
|
18-1-0 |
Asheville Axemen 34 |
Boston Rhinos 31 |
13-7-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
| IHOF BOWL 20 (2023) |
|
15-4-0 |
Superior Intellectuals 38 |
Vicksburg Vipers 10 |
15-5-0 |
|
BOX |
LOG |
|
